Rachel Seigel

Most of us probably remember writing a book report at least once during our time in school. We dutifully described the plot, the setting, the characters, and any other crucial data that would let our teachers know that we’d actually read and understood the book. As we advanced into high school and university, book reports shifted to book reviews, and whether we realize it or not, there is a subtle difference which we should be remembering when we review a book. Unlike a book report, whose purpose is to offer the reader a summary of content, a review’s purpose is to critically assess the value of the book, and to recommend or not recommend it to other readers.

In my position as a buyer, I often rely on reviews to help me evaluate books for age appropriateness, quality, and potential interest to my customers. I particularly love reading reviews from bloggers whom I trust, because I can count on a them for a thoughtful, honest analysis of the book they’re reviewing, and from that I can make an informed decision. What I don’t like to see, (and I’ve seen professional newspaper reviews do this) is a detailed, point-by-point rehashing of the plot, and then just a line or two of analysis.

When reading review,nI want just the briefest of summaries so I have an idea of what the book is about, and then I want to get to the heart of what you thought and why. I think it was around second year university where my TA patiently explained to me over coffee how necessary it was to start moving away from talking about the plot, and to start analyzing the novel. This is advice I still take to heart, and recommend to anybody who writes reviews for fun, or professionally.

The guidelines for one of the journals I review for suggest no more than 100 words of a 250-300 word review be devoted to plot, and I find that in most cases (once in a while a novel is just too complicated to summarize in 100 words and I’ll stretch it to 150) this is entirely possible. There is so much you can tell a reader without giving away key portions of the novel. You can talk about whether or not the story entertained you. You can talk about the authenticity of the characters, the emotional impact, etc….

So next time you prepare to write a review of the latest book that you loved or hated, challenge yourself to summarize the story in 10 lines or less, and spend the rest of the review talking about the book- not the plot.

Rachel Seigel is a Sales/Marketing Rep and the Fiction/Picture book Buyer for EduReference Publisher’s Direct Inc. in Ontario. She also maintains a personal blog at and can be found on Twitter as @rachelnseigel.

6 Responses to

  1. Kim May 22 2013 at 11:40 pm #

    I agree with you. The reviews that I find most helpful aren’t about the plot, but how the reviewer felt about the book and what they think it’s strength and weaknesses are. Plus, if you write a review without talking too much about the plot you can definitely keep out all the spoilers.

  2. Annie May 23 2013 at 2:14 pm #

    I totally agree.

    If I wanted to know what the book was about, I’d read the book. Or the summary offered by the publisher which is easily available. If I’m reading a review I want to know what that person brings to it – their perspective and humor or intelligence or insight or opinion. I read reviews because I want to understand the intersection between that person and the book – not the book itself. And definitely in that intersection I’m also looking for their view of appropriateness and quality because I trust what the reviewer brings to the table in that discussion.

  3. itmatcheswiththecolo May 24 2013 at 4:45 am #

    Pub(lishing) Crawl it matches with the color of christian louboutin australia the tiestylo mont blanc discount stylo mont blanc discount

  4. fireofficialssaidchr May 24 2013 at 4:47 am #

  5. louboutinweddingshoe May 24 2013 at 10:11 am #

    Pub(lishing) Crawl louboutin wedding shoes originals and replicas — 公司新闻 — abraham0225

  6. Alexa (Loves Books) May 27 2013 at 1:04 am #

    I very much agree with what you have to say about reviews. When I first started, I was all about rehashing the plot for my reviews! Eventually, I realized I was basically doing something that wasn’t necessary since I include summaries in all my reviews. I started sharing my personal opinion and reactions to the novel, and I think that’s really what makes my reviews strong at this point.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.