Practicing Like I Mean to Perform

Years ago, when I was in competitive dance, my instructor often told the group we should practice like we meant to perform. Which meant that from the very beginning of putting together a new routine—learning new steps and memorizing choreography—we had to smile (or make whatever facial expressions were appropriate for that style of dance). We had to dance “full out,” including jumps and turns, and other things that we could have “marked” that early in the process. In the months and weeks leading up to performances, we put on a show every time. We gave it our best even when we’d done the whole dance twenty times that day and had twenty more to go.

The idea was that we’d get so used to doing the dance correctly every time, right down to replacing expressions of concentration with whatever was appropriate for that style of dance, we’d unconsciously do the same during the performance.

We practiced like we meant to perform.

Writing is not a performance art (as author Elizabeth Bear says). And thank goodness for that. But writing as if someone’s going to read this draft still benefits me. Here are some things I like to keep in mind, even as I’m writing my first draft:

1. I have a plan before I go in.

This doesn’t mean The Plan can’t change. It usually does. But The Plan gives me an idea of what the whole thing should look like—what moods and feelings I want to convey to the reader. When The Plan has to change, I don’t just adjust that one spot. I go through everything I have and figure out how the one change affects the rest. I revise The Plan accordingly.

2. I research as I go.

For big things I know about ahead of time, I research during The Plan stages. (Sometimes research will change The Plan if what I originally thought I’d do doesn’t actually work like I thought it should.) But you know those sentences where you realize you don’t actually know what grows in that climate, or when the harvest is, or…how the whole situation works? And it’s really just one line, so maybe it’s not that big a deal…

I research it right then. It’s one of those details that will make the world feel more real. More believable. And I do it then so I don’t have to do it later. You know, after I’ve forgotten that I wanted to research something. I don’t want to risk leaving in a lazy line. (Sometimes I really do need to move on, so I leave myself a comment on that detail.)

3. I keep a critical eye on my first drafts as I write them—and I fix things.

Some days, it’s important to just write through and not look back. It can be easy to get caught up in a revision loop, never moving forward. Fixing as you go may not work for people prone to the revision loop. I’m not one of them, though. At least when it comes to the first draft. I like to push forward and see that wordcount rise.

So when I notice that the last few paragraphs I wrote feel emotionally thin, I go back. I layer in the emotion right away. This is useful for me because it puts me back in touch with my character, but it also makes that first draft better. Same with choosing the right word, making sure the motivation is clear, grammar and punctuation issues—whatever. And the more aware of any particular problem I become, the more able I am to spot it sooner.

That sort of awareness eventually becomes second nature. I don’t have to think as much about going back to cut weasel words because I didn’t write them in the first place.

Yes, this does slow down my first-draft process. Gone are the years when I could write 7,000 words a day without breaking a sweat. Now I’m more unconsciously critical of my own work, even before it hits the page, but my first drafts are stronger. Getting those things right the first time—and continuing to make them better with every revision—makes my final manuscript that much better.

Note that I still said revision. I don’t expect to have a perfect first draft. (If only!!!) The first draft is only a foundation to build the real thing off, but if I have that first draft in good shape, I can focus on more interesting story issues. I work on spotting higher-level issues that I didn’t notice in the first draft. That way, when I start my next book, I can keep those things in mind, too, and fix them as I see them. They, too, can become things I unconsciously fix before they’re ever a problem.

All that said, there is no wrong way to write. Everyone writes differently, and this is simply what works for me — writing like someone’s going to read that draft. (And someone usually does. I have a friend who likes to read my stories as they drip out of my head. She’s brave. Crazy, but brave.)

What about you guys? Do you watch your first draft, like I do? Or do you power forward and do the real heavy lifting in the revision? What works best for you?


11 Responses to Practicing Like I Mean to Perform

  1. Rowenna Jun 12 2015 at 10:31 am #

    I definitely watch my first draft. Common advice is often “silence your inner editor” but mine often points out good stuff! It’s easier to fix a wandering plotline before it flounders too far, and it’s better for me to hash out some worldbuilding and research lines before something wrong gets thoroughly enmeshed. That said, sometimes enough is enough and you have to let yourself write.

    I majored in French, and when writing papers, I often included a note when I had to look up a specific word. It wasn’t worth stopping writing to look up a single word. I use that mindset a lot now Teeny detail? Minor discrepancy that two seconds with the “Search” tool will fix? Note it and move on.

    • Jodi Jun 12 2015 at 3:43 pm #

      Yes, my inner editor is very useful. And if I let her boss me around a little bit in the first draft, everyone is happier with the result.

      But this method isn’t for everyone, and that’s okay!

  2. Caryn Caldwell Jun 12 2015 at 11:37 am #

    I am so happy to see this, Jodi! Thank you for posting it! I’ve heard so many people preaching about just pushing through to get a horrible rough draft, writing as many words per day as possible and saving all revisions for later. It paralyzes me when I do that, though, because I know I’m just making so much more work for myself later on. I know there will always be revisions, but it still feels nice to have a scene working as well as I can get it to work before I leave it behind. And, yes, it does make my first draft slower. THANK YOU for acknowledging that, because I do torture myself for being a slow first-drafter because of this process.

    Am now bookmarking this for inspiration later on, when I need it — because I know I will. 🙂

    • Jodi Jun 12 2015 at 3:44 pm #

      You’re welcome! I know so many people who have nightmarish first drafts and they go through and do WONDERS to fix them. But that’s not me. (Mine are nightmarish enough as it is.) And it doesn’t have to be you, either. While true, you can’t fix a blank page, if you know something’s wrong, might as well fix it right then, if you can.

  3. Marc Vun Kannon Jun 12 2015 at 4:16 pm #

    Novel writing as a spectator sport. A Monty Python sketch I call ‘Novel writing from Dorset’. Easy to find on Youtube, it’s a sketch from their Matching Tie and Handkerchief album.

    I write my first draft as if someone’s reading it because someone is: Me. If you aren’t your own first editor and first reader, what are you?

    • Jodi Jun 14 2015 at 7:04 pm #

      Totally right. You are your own first reader and editor, and you need to be pleased with the story, first and foremost!

      Thanks for the link!

  4. Logan Jun 14 2015 at 3:43 pm #

    Thanks, Marc. Hey, Jodi… let’s here it from you, too! Give us a big: “Thanks Marc.” At least say (something) since you acknowledged everyone else’s response. The more people you’re friendly to, the more fans you’ll acquire. And remember that men are people, too!

    • Jodi Jun 14 2015 at 7:03 pm #

      Hi Logan. I appreciate you looking out for your fellow commenter, but I wasn’t snubbing Marc. (And the implication that I’d ignore him because he’s a guy is just rude.) His comment came in after I’d finished replying to comments for the day (see time stamps). For my own mental health, I try to take weekends off email and other work-related things — and that includes replying to comments.

      • Marc Vun Kannon Jun 15 2015 at 9:25 pm #

        I’ve never felt ignored by anyone at Pub Crawl, in any of its incarnations.

        • Jodi Jun 15 2015 at 10:47 pm #

          I’m really glad to hear that, Marc.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.