Guest Post: Writing books or working pub?

Biljana here! Today I have Kerrie Byrne McCreadie with a guest post about choosing writing or publishing as a career. Take it away, Kerrie!

“But what are you going to do?”

Majoring in English always seemed to be a very puzzling thing for those around me. It took me five and a half years to finish my undergraduate degree, and I probably couldn’t count the number of times this question came up. I also couldn’t count the number of ways I’ve responded. Writer. Editor. Book publicist. Agent. Designer. All noble causes, all professions inhabited by creative and brilliant people. But somewhere, in answering that penetrating question—with all its strength of will in making me feel like my degree would be ultimately useless—I got lost in the possible options and forgot to think about the most important thing: what did I want to do in the first place?

You learn early that being a writer isn’t considered a “realistic” career. Going into editing, that can work. But writing, being an author, not so much. I’m still fairly certain that the Grade 11 Careers class I was forced to take (a Canadian rite of passage) existed just to tell me that my dream jobs (at the time: writer, musical theatre performer, etc.) were impractical, and that I was unreasonable.

I can still see my teacher rolling her eyes.

What they don’t tell you in Careers class is that it’s probably not that much more impossible to become a writer than it is to become an editor in this economic climate. Becoming a writer who creates a six-figure novel? Not so likely. But becoming a writer at all? It’s hard, it takes passion and dedication—but it does happen. And it isn’t really less possible than being an editor. But we’re told it is. We’re told as young writers that the publishing industry is the smarter, easier choice. Not only is that not necessarily true, but it also belittles the work done by the incredible, driven people in the industry. There are publishers who spend their entire lives making sure other peoples’ books do well. People who work in the industry are often ambitious and passionate and…well. Practically superhuman, in some cases.

But still, I really wanted to be an editor; and, admittedly, it wasn’t just because of Careers. I love editing, I love being the person who gets to polish something beautiful into something perfect. At this point I have a little more than year of experience in the Toronto publishing world. Not a lot. I’m a baby, and I know it—but it’s enough to get a peek. I worked as an intern at a small publisher, sorting through submissions and slush. At the same small publisher, I worked as a typesetter and graphic designer. This past summer I have been working as an assistant for the president of a literary agency. These have all been really rewarding experiences and I’ve learned a lot. Publishing is hard. There’s a lot on the line for everyone emotionally, mentally, and financially. Doing design on a fast-paced publishing schedule is one of the most challenging jobs I’ve had so far, and seeing how agents function while they work is awe-inspiring. So many people in this industry work 17-18 hour days with hardly any weekends, just because they love it so much.

As I’m starting to grow into a publishing toddler, this experience has given me a pretty startling realization. I knew going into these internships that I wanted to write, that I always have wanted to write. But somewhere along the way I started letting my Careers teacher’s voice whisper in my ear. I am dedicated to continuing to educate myself on how to edit more thoroughly and how to design more beautifully. I’m just starting to get good enough to freelance reliably. But what I really want to focus on  at the moment is my writing.

It’s not to say that some people can’t balance both. I know some wonderful ladies and gents who pull off doing both with style. There is definitely value in being both a writer and involved in the industry, whether it gives you a greater understanding of what’s required of you to get yourself published or whether it lends you empathy towards your clients. But that life is only suited to some very specific people. I’ve met some ex-agents-turned-writers who realized that they loved their own work more than working on other peoples’, even if they ultimately loved doing both. And I know plenty of once-writers who seem to be leaning towards becoming editors.

Me? Somehow, coming out of all of this has ended a five-year novel writing block, and I’m happily typing away at a new project every spare moment I have. My industry experience helped me make some major life decisions, like moving on to grad school instead of going on to a publishing certificate without a single doubt. Doing this work now means I got the experience while I had as many doors open as possible. I’m able to acknowledge that just because I’m interested in industry work doesn’t mean I have to commit to it 100% now when I’m only 23. Even if my career advisor told me I should.

Besides, there are so many other things I can do with my English degree.

(Like getting a PhD!)

Kerrie McCreadieKERRIE BYRNE MCCREADIE has dipped her toes/feet/shins/waist into the publishing world in various ways over the past few years, and thinks the whole industry is pretty fascinating. You can follow her on twitter, or find her on her brand new blog. She is currently writing a rather depressing fairy tale contemporary, and will thank anyone for holding her hand as she starts her PhD applications this fall.


10 Responses to Guest Post: Writing books or working pub?

  1. Jaaron Aug 20 2014 at 8:28 am #

    Hi Kerrie!
    I really connected with this post! I am also 23 and just starting out in the Toronto publishing world and I found your post really motivating, so thank you! I wish you all the best with your writing and the PhD! 🙂

    • Kerrie Aug 20 2014 at 4:45 pm #

      I’m so glad to hear that you enjoyed the post, Jaaron! It’s an uphill battle, but one that’s absolutely worth undertaking—there are so many great ways to get involved in Toronto. Good luck, and thank you for your well wishes.

  2. Chris Bailey Aug 20 2014 at 9:06 am #

    Bravo! I listened to the practical advice, and while I gained a lot of valuable life experience (bleah!) I wish I had just written all the words. Now feverishly trying to catch up!

    • Kerrie Aug 22 2014 at 11:50 pm #

      Never too late! : ) Yeah, that’s the one thing about getting the experience—I definitely don’t have as much of a back log of writing as I’d like to!

  3. Maybelle L Aug 20 2014 at 2:59 pm #

    You go girl! Keep writing and giving what you got! (I will offer to hold your hand as you start your applications this fall hehe.)

    • Kerrie Aug 23 2014 at 12:08 am #

      Ahaha thank you, Maybelle! I look forward to many coffees over which we can chat.

  4. laurawardle Aug 22 2014 at 9:39 am #

    Fantastic post, Kerrie! I did just short of two years of an English degree, believing that I needed to be practical. I ended up dropping out–best thing I ever did, truly!–and got a job in a library. Three years later, I’m a full-time school librarian and writing fantasy books for teens whenever I’m not at the day job. You can do anything you put your mind to, girl. Follow your heart and the trust that the rest will follow. Forget about balance–it doesn’t exist. You just have to tilt in whichever direction you need to at that time. <3

    Good luck with your PhD applications!

    • Kerrie Aug 23 2014 at 12:10 am #

      Thank you Laura! That does sound like a great transition—I have a friend who works in a library and loves every moment of it, and writes to her heart’s content on the side! : ) I’m so glad you enjoyed the post.

  5. Cassie G Sep 8 2014 at 10:57 am #

    I loved loved LOVED this post. I come from the opposite stand point. I’ve known I wanted to be an editor since I started reading at age 2. I love working with already-there material and making it wonderful. And when I tell people I want to edit, they look at me all confused and say, “you mean write?” No, I mean edit. I’ve just graduated and I’m applying everywhere. So far, no luck, but I’m headed to NYC soon, so fingers crossed. 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.